| 1 | Hovhannes Harutyun Aghanuryants | 1821 – 1824 |
| 2 | Harutyun Galutsyan | 1825 – 1833 |
| 3 | Hovhannes Avdalyants | 1833 – 1863 |
| 4 | Tadeos Ter-Stepanosyan | 1865 – 1883 |
| 5 | Karapet Muradyan | 1883 – 1886 |
| 6 | Herbert A.Stark | 1887 – 1890 |
| 7 | De la Fosse | 1891 – 1892 |
| 8 | R.E.O Bird | 1893 – 1895 |
| 9 | C.Scott Platts | 1895 |
| 10 | Tadeos Ter-Stepanosyan | 1896 – 1897 |
| 11 | C. Collins | 1898 – 1899 |
| 12 | M.P.S. Milstead | 1901 – 1906 |
| 13 | M.A. Pemberton | 1907 – 1908 |
| 14 | Gevorg Turyan | 1908 – 1911 |
| 15 | Fr. Vardan Vardanyan | 1912 |
| 16 | H.W.B. Morino | 1913 – 1917 |
| 17 | J.O. Evans | 1917 – 1918 |
| 18 | Simon Mkhikyan | 1918 – 1920 |
| 19 | Herbert A.Stark | 1920 – 1923 |
| 20 | A.E. Clark | 1923 – 1932 |
| 21 | M.K. Kuckoo | 1933 – 1934 |
| 22 | C.A. Newberry | 1935 – 1936 |
| 23 | Grigor Kirakosyan | 1937 |
| 24 | M.H. Davis | 1938 – 1939 |
| 25 | Nerses Hakobyan | 1940 – 1942 |
| 26 | Martiros Barseghyan | 1943 – 1944 |
| 27 | Levon Galemqyaryan | 1945 |
| 28 | E.J. Hughes | 1946 – 1952 |
| 29 | Vahan Poladyan | 1952 – 1988 |
| 30 | Sonia John | – 2005 |
| 31 | Very Rev. Father Oshagan Gulgulyan | 2005 – 2009 |
| 32 | Very Rev. Father Khoren Hovhannisyan | 2009 – 2013 |
| 33 | Very Rev. Fr. Zaven Yazichyan | 2013 – 2016 |
| 34 | Very Rev Fr. Movses Sargsyan | 2016 – |
